| Photos (see all 12 | slideshow) |
| Dorothy Dwan | ... | Dorothy | |
| Mary Carr | ... | Aunt Em | |
| Virginia Pearson | ... | Lady Vishuss | |
| Bryant Washburn | ... | Prince Kynd | |
| Josef Swickard | ... | Prime Minister Kruel | |
| Charles Murray | ... | Wizard of Oz | |
| Oliver Hardy | ... | Farmhand (as Oliver N. Hardy) | |
| William Hauber | ... | Undetermined Role | |
| William Dinus | ... | Undetermined Role | |
| Frank Alexander | ... | Uncle Henry | |
| Otto Lederer | ... | Ambassador Wikked | |
| Frederick Ko Vert | ... | Phantom of the Basket | |
| Larry Semon | ... | Toymaker / Farmhand | |
| rest of cast listed alphabetically: | |||
| Spencer Bell | ... | Snowball (uncredited) | |
| Chester Conklin | ... | Undetermined Role (uncredited) (unconfirmed) | |
| Wanda Hawley | ... | Undetermined Role (uncredited) (unconfirmed) | |
| Allen 'Farina' Hoskins | ... | Palace Guard (uncredited) | |
Directed by | |||
| Larry Semon | |||
Writing credits | ||
| L. Frank Baum | (novel "The Wonderful Wizard of Oz") | |
| Frank Joslyn Baum | (adaptation) (as L. Frank Baum Jr.) & | |
| Leon Lee | (adaptation) & | |
| Larry Semon | (adaptation) | |
| Leon Lee | (titles) | |
Produced by | |||
| I.E. Chadwick | .... | executive producer (uncredited) | |
| Larry Semon | .... | producer (uncredited) | |
Original Music by | |||
| Marc Glassman | (1996) | ||
| Robert Israel | (2005 alternate version) | ||
| Steffan Presley | (1996) | ||
| Rosa Rio | (1986) | ||
| Julius K. Johnson | (uncredited) | ||
Cinematography by | |||
| Frank B. Good | (photographed by) (as Frank Good) | ||
| Hans F. Koenekamp | (photographed by) (as H.F. Koenenkamp) | ||
| Leonard Smith | (photographed by) | ||
Film Editing by | |||
| Sam Zimbalist | |||
Art Direction by | |||
| Robert Stevens | |||
Costume Design by | |||
| Frederick Ko Vert | (uncredited) | ||
Second Unit Director or Assistant Director | |||
| William King | .... | assistant director | |
Sound Department | |||
| Vladislav Kvapil | .... | recording director (2005 alternate version) | |
Stunts | |||
| William Hauber | .... | stunt double: Larry Semon & Dorothy Dwan (uncredited) | |
Costume and Wardrobe Department | |||
| Larry Semon | .... | costumes: Tin Man and Scare Crow | |
Music Department | |||
| Robert Israel | .... | conductor (2005 alternate version) | |
| Robert Israel | .... | music arranger (2005 alternate version) | |
| Julius K. Johnson | .... | musician: organ (at the premiere) (uncredited) | |
| Louis La Rondelle | .... | orchestrator (at the premiere) (uncredited) | |
| Harry F. Silverman | .... | conductor (at the premiere) (uncredited) | |
Other crew | |||
| Edwin G. Hitchcok | .... | publicity director (uncredited) | |
| Steve Miranda | .... | assistant publicity director (uncredited) | |
|
|
|
|
|
| The Wizard of Oz | The Phantom Rider | Big Fish | Willow | The Galloping Ghost |
|
IMDb User Rating:
|
IMDb User Rating:
|
IMDb User Rating:
|
IMDb User Rating:
|
IMDb User Rating:
|
| Full cast and crew | Company credits | External reviews |
| News articles | IMDb Comedy section | IMDb USA section |
| Add this title to MyMovies |
Watching an unfamiliar version of a much-loved favourite is a little like journeying into a parallel dimension: one in which everything is recognisable, but nothing is quite the same. MGM's definitive 1939 version of L. Frank Baum's dark children's story is more familiar to the modern world than the majority of films released in the last 12 months. In fact, the majority of the population will be completely unaware of the fact that the Judy Garland version was at least the fourth to be filmed. To add to the strangeness of this 1925 version and in terms of the storyline familiar to us all, it is very strange Oliver Hardy (billed as Oliver N. Hardy) appears sans Stan Laurel as a villain who, while not disguised as the Tin Man, acts as the potential romantic interest for Dorothy (I told you it was strange).
This version is the brainchild of one Larry Semon, who co-wrote, directed and stars as the hero, a toymaker, and the scarecrow. Now, I've watched movies for the best part of thirty years and, until seeing this flick I don't recall ever coming across Semon before. Apparently, he was hugely popular back in the twenties, vying with Chaplin and Keaton for box office status, but today he is unknown. Perhaps this is because he died of pneumonia in 1928, at the age of thirty-nine, or perhaps it is because, on the evidence of this film he really can't hold a light to the other comedy stars of the day. Watching this film, seeing Semon caper through a stream of slapstick situations, I couldn't help thinking how much better Keaton would have done it all. The timing, the moves, everything. Semon's career was apparently already in decline when he made this, his only feature, and it virtually signalled the end of his career as a major star at least.
The story bears no resemblance to the book, or the 1939 version (which, itself, bears only a passing resemblance to the book). For a start, Dorothy is no virginal 14-year-old in a gingham dress, Dorothy Dwan's Dorothy is a sensuous wench of 18 who spends much of her time fluttering the lashes of her big eyes with the tip of her finger inserted coyly in her mouth. She also seems to be playing Hardy (who, I swear, is the image of Meat Loaf in this flick) off against Semon's farmhand, blowing hot and cold between them. Dorothy's Uncle Henry (Frank Alexander), within the shadow of whose girth a relatively slimline Hardy could easily hide, is a rather cantankerous soul, given to beating both his workforce and his niece, while Aunt Em (Mary Carr) is little more than a doormat who disappears after thirty minutes (without being missed by anyone who knew her), and is never seen again. Toto is nowhere to be seen, and neither is the wicked witch.
Less than twenty minutes into the pic, and it was obvious that this movie wasn't about the Wizard of Oz at all, but was merely a showcase for Semon's failing slapstick talents. It was fully forty minutes before Dorothy along with Uncle Henry, Semon, Hardy, and a stereotyped black guy named Snowball (played by Spencer Bell, but billed as G. Howe Black) is finally whisked off to Oz in a shed carried off by an extremely impressive storm. It turns out that Dorothy is actually the Queen of Oz, and was left on Uncle Henry and that old aunt that used to hang around's doorstep as a babe, spirited there by the wicked Prime Minister Kruel. Finally reinstated to her rightful position within two minutes of arriving in Oz, Dorothy plays little part in the remaining half of the movie, which focuses on Semon's attempts to escape from Oz's lion infested dungeons.
While Wizard of Oz boasts some impressive special effects for its era, and some terrific stuntwork, were it not for the huge popularity of its successor it is doubtful whether this version would be remembered today, let alone released on DVD (and shame on the Pickwick UK DVD version for passing this off as a Laurel & Hardy flick). Worth seeing only as a curio, Semon's version has little going for it and, with too many slow sequences and too much self-indulgence on Semon's part (check out the number of close-ups he receives compared to the rest of the cast), this film provides unsatisfactory entertainment.