McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971)

Director:

Robert Altman

Writers:

Edmund Naughton (novel)
Robert Altman (screenplay) ...

Release Date:

24 June 1971 (USA)

Genre:

Drama | Western

Tagline:

Name Your Poison.

Plot:

A gambler and a prostitute become business partners in a remote Old West mining town, and their enterprise thrives until a large corporation arrives on the scene.

Plot Keywords:

Madam | Whorehouse | Pacific Northwest | Fight | Female Nudity

Awards:

Nominated for Oscar. Another 2 nominations

Cast

Warren Beatty	...	John McCabe
Julie Christie	...	Constance Miller
Rene Auberjonois	...	Sheehan
William Devane	...	The Lawyer
John Schuck	...	Smalley
Corey Fischer	...	Mr. Elliot
Bert Remsen	...	Bart Coyle
Shelley Duvall	...	Ida Coyle
Keith Carradine	...	Cowboy
Michael Murphy	...	Eugene Sears
Antony Holland	...	Ernie Hollander
Hugh Millais	...	Butler
Manfred Schulz	...	Kid
Jace Van Der Veen	...	Breed (as Jace Vander Veen)
Jackie Crossland	...	Lily

Also Known As:

The Presbyterian Church Wager (USA) (working title)
McCabe & Mrs. Miller (Austria) (West Germany) [de]
A Noite Fez-se Para Amar (Portugal) (original subtitled version) [pt]
Del mismo barro (Argentina) (video title) [es]
Entimos kyria kai o hartopaiktis, I... (Greece) [el]
I compari (Italy) [it]
I... entimos kyria kai o hartopaiktis (Greece) [el]
Jogos e Trapaças - Quando os Homens São Homens (Brazil) [pt]
John McCabe (France) [fr]
Los vividores (Spain) [es]
McCabe & Mrs. Miller (Finland) [fi]
McCabe i pani Miller (Poland) [pl]
Onde os Homens São Homens (Brazil) (TV title) [pt]
Quando os Homens São Homens (Brazil) [pt]
Vestens syndige par - McCabe & Mrs. Miller (Denmark) [da]

Runtime:

120 min | Argentina:121 min

Country:

USA

Language:

English

Color:

Color (Technicolor)

Aspect Ratio:

2.35 : 1

Sound Mix:

Mono

Certification:

Singapore:M18 | UK:15 (1992) | UK:X (1971) | Portugal:M/12 | Germany:16 (DVD rating) | Spain:18 | Argentina:16 | Finland:K-16 | Sweden:15 | USA:R

Filming Locations:

British Columbia, Canada

Company:

David Foster Productions

Trivia:

Ranked #8 on the American Film Institute's list of the 10 greatest films in the genre "Western" in June 2008.

Goofs:

Continuity: When the young man in the tall hat is leaving, he hugs each of the girls in turn. In the shot from the front, he the one girl and Ida Coyle is stepping up for her hug. The shot changes to the view from the left, where the hug of the first girl is repeated and Ida Coyle again steps forward.

Quotes:

[first lines]
John McCabe: [muttering to himself] I told you... Think I'm stupid?... S'exactly what I said. Six, six of 'em...

Movie Connections:

Featured in Easy Riders, Raging Bulls: How the Sex, Drugs and Rock 'N' Roll Generation Saved Hollywood (2003)

Soundtrack:

The Stranger Song

Within

Spoilers herein.

Filmmakers - intelligent ones - have to choose where they live in a film. The ordinary ones attach themselves to the narrative, usually the spoken narrative, so we get faces and clear, ordered speech to tell us what is going on. These are the most formulaic because there are after all only so many stories that are presentable.

Some attach themselves to characters, dig in and let those characters deliver a tale and situation. Often with the Italians and Italian-Americans, the camera swoops on a tether attached to these characters. I consider this lazy art unless there is some extraordinary insight into the relationship between actor and character.

And then there the few who attach themselves to a sense, a tone, a space. That situation has ideas and stories and talk, but they are only there as reflections from the facets of the place. Of the three, this is the hardest to do well; that's why so few try. And of those that do, most convey style only, not a place, not a whole presentation of the way the world works.

This film is about the best example I know where the world is 'real,' the situation governs everything and the primary substance is the presentation of a Shakespearian quality cosmology of fate.

The camera moves not so much with the story, but it enters and leaves. And there is not just one story, but many that we catch in glimpses. Words just appear in disorder as they do in life. Not everything is served up neat. We drift with the same arbitrariness as McCabe. It is not as meditative as 'Mood for Love' as it has something we can interpret as a story to distract us.

So as a matter of craft, this is an important film, one with painful fishhooks that stick. Beatty had already reinvented Hollywood with 'Bonny,' and was a co- conspirator in this. (If you are into double bills, see it with 'The Claim,' which is intended as a distanced remake/homage, that obliquely references Warren.)

Quite apart from the craft of the thing, and the turning of the Western on its head long before 'Unforgiven,' there are other values:

- the notion that actors are imported into a fictional world as whores. Not a new idea for sure, but so seamlessly and subtly injected here, it becomes just another one of the background stories. (Also referenced in 'Unforgiven.')

- the business about the preacher trying to wrestle some old school order from the overwhelming mechanics of arbitrary fate. This is the director's stance.

- the final concept that the whole thing, McCabe and church and all is an opium dream of the aptly named 'Constance,' dimly reinterpreting other events after the fashion of 'Edwin Drood.'

Ted's Evaluation -- 4 of 3: Every cineliterate person should experience this.