Directed by | |||
| Sanjay Leela Bhansali | |||
Writing credits | ||
| Saratchandra Chatterjee | (based on the novel by) (as Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay) | |
| Prakash Kapadia | (screenplay) and | |
| Sanjay Leela Bhansali | (screenplay) | |
| Prakash Kapadia | (dialogue) | |
Produced by | |||
| Gajendra Mishra | .... | executive producer | |
| Mohan Nayyar | .... | executive producer | |
| Bharat S. Shah | .... | producer (as Bharat Shah) | |
Original Music by | |||
| Ismail Darbar | |||
| Monty Sharma | (as Monty) | ||
Cinematography by | |||
| Binod Pradhan | |||
Film Editing by | |||
| Bela Segal | |||
Casting by | |||
| Suguna Sundaram | |||
Production Design by | |||
| Nitin Chandrakant Desai | |||
Art Direction by | |||
| Nitin Chandrakant Desai | |||
Costume Design by | |||
| Abu Jani | |||
| Sandeep Khosla | |||
| Neeta Lulla | |||
| Reza Shariffi | |||
Makeup Department | |||
| Surendra Dubey | .... | makeup artist: Vijayendra Ghatge | |
| Feroz | .... | makeup artist: Smita Jayakar | |
| Shaileja Gaikwad | .... | hair stylist | |
| Ravi Indulkar | .... | makeup artist: Shahrukh Khan | |
| Geeta Jadav | .... | hair stylist | |
| Jenny | .... | hair stylist: Smita Jayakar | |
| Atul Kadam | .... | makeup artist: Kiron Kher (as Atul) | |
| Fatima Kahn | .... | hair stylist | |
| Lata | .... | hair stylist | |
| Bhagya Laxmi | .... | hair stylist: Aishwarya Rai (as Bhagyalaxmi) | |
| Mala | .... | hair stylist: Dina Pathak | |
| Pradeep Mohate | .... | makeup artist: Aishwarya Rai (as Pradeep Nohate) | |
| Arun Pillai | .... | makeup artist | |
| Prasad | .... | makeup artist | |
| Sameer Roy | .... | makeup artist (as Sameer) | |
| Shahida Shaikh | .... | hair stylist: Madhuri Dixit (as Shahida) | |
| Sharad | .... | makeup artist: Milind Gunaji | |
| Shashi | .... | makeup artist: Jackie Shroff | |
| Vijay Shikare | .... | makeup artist | |
| Susan | .... | hair stylist: Aishwarya Rai | |
| Jaywant Thakre | .... | makeup artist: Madguri Dixit | |
| Wasim | .... | makeup artist | |
Production Management | |||
| Azim Shaikh | .... | assistant production manager | |
Second Unit Director or Assistant Director | |||
| Nishat Amber | .... | chief assistant director (as Amber Lal) | |
| Raj Ashraf | .... | assistant director | |
| Rohit Dheeraj | .... | assistant director | |
| Sid Jayakar | .... | trainee assistant director | |
| Amber Lall | .... | chief assistant director | |
| Sangeeta Manu | .... | assistant director | |
| Vikramaditya Motwane | .... | associate director | |
| Rashika Pradeep | .... | chief assistant director (as Rashika Pratap Singh) | |
| Vatsala Sikandar | .... | chief assistant director (as Vatsala Tyagi) | |
| Amit Suhas | .... | assistant director | |
| Ranjeet Gupta | .... | assistant director (uncredited) | |
Art Department | |||
| Dheeraj Akolkar | .... | art assistant | |
| Dinkar Balal | .... | art assistant (as Dinkar Ballal) | |
| Kuntal Joshi | .... | art assistant | |
| Eknath Kadam | .... | art assistant | |
| Nitin Kulkarni | .... | art assistant | |
| Tapan Roy | .... | art assistant | |
Sound Department | |||
| Vikram Biswas | .... | sound effects editor: Aradhana Sound Services | |
| Jitendra Chaudhary | .... | sound recordist | |
| Sajjan Choudhary | .... | sound effects editor: Aradhana Sound Services (as Sajaan Choudhry) | |
| Leslie Fernandes | .... | sound mixing engineer | |
| Baylon Fonseca | .... | DTS mix engineer | |
| Kunal Mehta | .... | dubbing matching | |
| Vikramaditya Motwane | .... | sound designer | |
| Arvind Rathod | .... | sound assistant | |
| Joe Rodrigues | .... | re-recording assistant (as Joseph Rodrigues) | |
| Kunal Sharma | .... | sound designer | |
| Karnail Singh | .... | sound effects editor: Aradhana Sound Services | |
| Vasant | .... | sound assistant (as Basant) | |
| Jayant Haldar | .... | assistant mixing engineer (uncredited) | |
Visual Effects by | |||
| Avishkar Dahiya | .... | president | |
| Tarn Fox | .... | digital compositor | |
| Marc Kolbe | .... | visual effects supervisor | |
| Craig A. Mumma | .... | visual effects supervisor | |
| Paul Naveen | .... | digital compositor | |
| Kondareddy Suresh | .... | compositor | |
| Jonah Loop | .... | visual effects consultant (uncredited) | |
| Robert Rossello | .... | main title designer (uncredited) | |
Stunts | |||
| Panduran Chavhan | .... | action assistant (as Pandu) | |
| Shyam Kaushal | .... | action director | |
| Pali | .... | action assistant | |
| Riyaz | .... | action assistant | |
| Heera Singh | .... | action assistant (as Hira) | |
Costume and Wardrobe Department | |||
| Ramkrishna Gaddam | .... | costumer: men | |
| Maqbool Shaikh | .... | costumer: men | |
| Rajkumar Yadav | .... | costumer: men | |
Editorial Department | |||
| Avijit Mitra | .... | promo editor | |
| K.N. Nayak | .... | color corrector: Adlabs | |
| Prakash Prabhu | .... | color corrector: Adlabs | |
| Tirupathi Reddy | .... | editing assistant (as Tirupati Reddy) | |
| Amit Shetty | .... | negative cutter: Adlabs | |
| Amitabh Shukla | .... | promo editor | |
Music Department | |||
| Bishwadeep Chatterjee | .... | background music recordist: Spectral Harmony | |
| Bishwadeep Chatterjee | .... | music engineer (as Biswadeep Chatterjee) | |
| Bishwadeep Chatterjee | .... | song mixer: Spectral Harmony | |
| Bishwadeep Chatterjee | .... | song recordist: Spectral Harmony (as Biswadeep Chatterjee) | |
| Madhuri Dixit | .... | playback singer | |
| Tanay Gajjar | .... | song recordist: Ava | |
| Shreya Ghoshal | .... | playback singer | |
| Parthiv Gohil | .... | musicial: singer, background music | |
| Zoheb Husain | .... | background music assistant | |
| Kay Kay | .... | playback singer (as K.K.) | |
| Kavita Krishnamurthy | .... | playback singer | |
| Irkramuddin Lochnoor | .... | song recording assistant: Spectral Harmony | |
| Birju Maharaj | .... | playback singer (as Pandit Birju Maharaju) | |
| Udit Narayan | .... | playback singer | |
| Ameya Nare | .... | background music assistant | |
| Jaspinder Narula | .... | playback singer | |
| Avinash Oak | .... | song recording assistant: Western Out Door | |
| Prakash Patel | .... | music arranger | |
| Yogesh Pradhan | .... | music arranger | |
| Taufiq Qureshi | .... | musician: background music, rhythm | |
| Vinod Rathod | .... | playback singer | |
| Aamir Shaikh | .... | song recording assistant: Spectral Harmony | |
| Daman Sood | .... | song recordist: Western Out-Door | |
| Tenny | .... | background music recordist: Spectral Harmony (as Abhijit Roy) | |
| Vasu | .... | song recordist assistant: Ava | |
Other crew | |||
| Dheeraj Akolkar | .... | direction assistant | |
| Salim Ali | .... | assistant: Aishwarya Rai | |
| Anand | .... | assistant: Milind Gunaji | |
| Anil | .... | assistant: Smita Jayakar | |
| Baba | .... | production staff: Bikaner | |
| Suvonkar Baneerjee | .... | direction assistant | |
| H. Banerjee | .... | subtitler | |
| Sikander Berry | .... | direction assistant (as Sikander Berry Kher) | |
| Vijay Bhalekar | .... | title designer | |
| Jitendra Bhatt | .... | nagra attendant | |
| Sandeep Bhosale | .... | security department | |
| S. Biyani | .... | consultant: finance and tax | |
| Rohit Singh Chauhan | .... | direction assistant | |
| Pradeep Choudhary | .... | direction assistant | |
| David | .... | assistant: Jackie Sheroff | |
| Sangeeta Gala | .... | direction assistant | |
| Manu Gautam | .... | direction assistant | |
| Shibani Ghosh | .... | direction assistant | |
| Amit Gupta | .... | direction assistant | |
| Harish | .... | nagra attendant | |
| Suhas Jahagirdar | .... | direction assistant | |
| Sid Jayakar | .... | direction assistant (as Siddarth Jayakar) | |
| Sanjay Jha | .... | production assistant | |
| John | .... | assistant: Ananya Khare | |
| Kamlesh | .... | production staff: Bikaner | |
| Pramod Karade | .... | choreography assistant: Vaibhavi Merchant | |
| Ashraf Khan | .... | direction assistant | |
| Saroj Khan | .... | choreographer | |
| Shabina Khan | .... | choreography assistant: Saroj Khan (as Shabana Khan) | |
| D. 'Mama' Khirade | .... | security department | |
| Marc Kolbe | .... | title designer: Digital Art Media (as Mark Kolbe) | |
| Krishna | .... | assistant: Madhuri Dixit | |
| Vijay Kumar | .... | consultant: finance and tax | |
| Nishat Laljee | .... | direction assistant | |
| Birju Maharaj | .... | choreographer (as Pandit Birju Maharaj) | |
| Malu | .... | choreographer (as Pappu-Malu) | |
| Santosh Mandal | .... | assistant: Kiron Kher | |
| Siddarth Marathe | .... | title designer | |
| Peter Martis | .... | public relations officer | |
| Vaibhavi Merchant | .... | choreographer | |
| D.K. Mishra | .... | nagra attendant | |
| Santosh Mishra | .... | production assistant | |
| Munni | .... | choreography assistant: Saroj Khan | |
| Himanshu Nanda | .... | publicity designer | |
| Rahul Nanda | .... | publicity designer | |
| Rakita Nanda | .... | web site designer | |
| Manoj Panchal | .... | assistant: Vijayndra Ghatge | |
| Devraj Panda | .... | production assistant | |
| Johnson Perera | .... | security department | |
| Binay Pradhan | .... | direction assistant | |
| Furqan Qureshi | .... | steam train coordinator | |
| Raju | .... | choreography assistant: Saroj Khan | |
| Zameer Rizvi | .... | nagra attendant | |
| Ruby | .... | choreography assistant: Pappu-Malu | |
| Sagar | .... | choreography assistant: Pappu-Malu | |
| Bhawar Sharma | .... | production staff: Bikaner | |
| Shashwati | .... | choreography assistant: Pandit Birju Maharaj | |
| Raju Shinde | .... | security department | |
| Santosh Singh | .... | production assistant | |
| Subhash | .... | assistant: Shahrukh Khan | |
| Sumit Upadhyay | .... | production assistant | |
| Abhishek Verma | .... | direction assistant | |
| Rashmi Verma | .... | choreography assistant: Vaibhavi Merchant | |
| Shekhar Verma | .... | consultant: finance and tax | |
| Vithal | .... | security department | |
| Baba Yadav | .... | assistant choreographer (as Baba) | |
| Rajnath Yadav | .... | production assistant | |
Thanks | |||
| P.C. Barua | .... | a tribute to the genius of | |
| Navin Bhansali | .... | dedicatee | |
| Saratchandra Chatterjee | .... | a tribute to the genius of (as Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay) | |
| Rituparno Ghosh | .... | acknowledgment | |
| Debajyoti Mishra | .... | acknowledgment | |
| Sourindramohan Mukherjee | .... | acknowledgment | |
| Bimal Roy | .... | a tribute to the genius of | |
|
|
|
|
|
| Gone with the Wind | Giant | Les enfants du siècle | America, America | I vitelloni |
|
IMDb User Rating: |
IMDb User Rating: |
IMDb User Rating: |
IMDb User Rating: |
IMDb User Rating: |
| Full cast and crew | Company credits | External reviews |
| News articles | IMDb Musical section | IMDb India section |
I owned this film for 8 months but did not see it because of all the negative hype on the board. Then I took the plunge. First off let me say that I was not a great Saratchandra admirer. His stories (except SWAMI) mostly portrayed women as weak minded, subservient (maybe true to the time, but not to be admired), and men as weak and mostly well bred but not well educated. I had no real recollection of the story as written. And, not being a great Dilip Kumar fan, I never watched the old version. So, I have no comparisons to draw, no plot line differences to talk about.
I came away moved by the tragic love story that unfolded. It was not flawless, most Bollywood movies are not.
Negatives - the sets were beautiful but over the top, ditto for the costumes. The duo dance was a great way to compare Aish vs Madhuri dancing skills (both were pretty even matched for me) but in the story line it was quite silly and should not have been there. There was no real need for the the two to meet, but this was Mr, Bhansali's directorial license. Chandramukhi's kotha and environs were lifted straight from Pakeezah, which was a very stylized movie and not authentic.
Positives: Shahrukh Khan gave a very restrained performance, the silent tears accompanied with an anguish that only his eyes portrayed was a real departure from the screwed-up face crying. He was very very good in the drunk bits, very good in the anguished bits. It is remarkable how much this actor is accused of being typecast when every other year he pulls out an amazing performance - Dil Se (1998), Asoka (2001) and Devdas (2002) are all departures from his usual typecast romantic hero image. Recent roles in Swades and KANK are even more varied. The detractors will keep saying he overacted, or he portrayed no emotions, for me this was a truly great role as an anguished lover. Mr. Khan - your best actor award for this role in Devdas was well deserved.
Madhuri - what can one say about this truly great icon? She was amazing, you felt her pain, her caring, her selfless love, the moments between her and Shahrukh sizzled. And her dancing was brilliant.
Aish - was a bit wooden at times, but not always. She had a chemistry with Shahrukh that was understated until she was beyond his reach, but come on - the woman looks amazing, is there any doubt that a hundred Devdas types are dying for her?? She was better as the movie progressed to the more serious part.
The movie went into an emotional downward spiral a third of the way in and I sat there moved and almost crying for these tortured souls the rest of the two hours.
The movie was eye candy in the sets and costumes department. The two leading ladies were stunning, Shahrukh was easy on the eye, yet there was something that did detract from this being a great film. Upon much thinking I have come to the conclusion that it was the over the top beauty of everything that really made everything a little unreal for me. How could such perfect people have such imperfect lives? In essence the little black mark on the lip was missing and that left me a little dissatisfied.
If Mr. Bhansali had stated that this was an adaptation from the original novel, people would forgive him the fact that Devdas in his version is a mature man and knows his mind (although fails to act decisively on it), and the fact that an aristocratic lady visits a courtesan's establishment and the two dance together.
If you do not compare with what did or did not come before, this was an intense emotional experience, anchored by great performances from Shahrukh, Madhuri and yes, even Aish.