Home
| Search
| Now Playing
| News
| My Movies
| Games
| Boards
| Help
| US Movie Showtimes
| Top 250
| Register
| Recommendations
| Widgets
Box Office
| Index
| Trailers
| Jobs
|
IMDbPro.com - Free Trial
| IMDb Resume
Copyright © 1990-2008
IMDb.com, Inc.
Terms and Privacy Policy under which this service is provided to you.
An
company.
Advertise on IMDb.
License our content.
Quicklinks
Top Links
trailers and videosfull cast and crewtriviaofficial sitesmemorable quotesOverview
main detailscombined detailsfull cast and crewcompany creditstv scheduleAwards & Reviews
user commentsexternal reviewsnewsgroup reviewsawardsuser ratingsparents guiderecommendationsmessage boardPlot & Quotes
plot summaryplot synopsisplot keywordsAmazon.com summarymemorable quotesFun Stuff
triviagoofssoundtrack listingcrazy creditsalternate versionsmovie connectionsFAQOther Info
merchandising linksbox office/businessrelease datesfilming locationstechnical specslaserdisc detailsDVD detailsliterature listingsNewsDeskPromotional
taglines trailers and videos posters photo galleryExternal Links
showtimesofficial sitesmiscellaneousphotographssound clipsvideo clipsIMDb user comments for
Slogans (2001)
7 out of 7 people found the following comment useful :-
An interesting, if slightly flat, look at communism, 15 April 2004
Author: Vladimir from Sydney, Australia
Before I start this comment, I might take a minute to state that I know very little about the country of Albania, nor about the communist politics that go on in that state. Living in a big city in a capitalist country, interpreting this film is somewhat difficult and can be called into question, at least as far as I'm concerned. So bear that in mind as I write.
The film "Slogans" is set in a remote Albanian village, in a communist state. It is viewed primarily through the eyes of Andre, a young teacher recently arrived in the town and hence under constant scrutiny from the citizens. The plot revolves largely around him and his fellow teachers as they lead their students in building huge slogans for the communist party in rocks on the side of a hill. If this plot intrigues you in a slightly whimsical kind of way, you'll know what my motivation was to watch it in the first place.
On the surface, the plot seems to be nothing more than a tale of alienation and politics revolving around the somewhat tedious occupation of building these slogans from rocks and painting the rocks to make them stand out. But deeper down there are more inner workings.
The way I see it, the film is simply a satirical piece on the failure and hollowness of communism as a governing rule. The slogans are symbolic of this; the whole job is done for the purposes of this supposedly wonderfully fulfilling pursuit, but in the end, all they are is just words. The fact that so much of the plot revolves around these words seems to suggest that, in a similar way, the communist system itself revolves around words and little more. The brave and inspirational words are supposed to incite the masses to enthusiasm, and yet, as the film illustrates, the words are so fragile that a simple flow of rain or the trotting of goats can unsettle them and they lose all meaning.
It's interesting to note the other ways in which the writers have stressed the importance of words (ie. propaganda) in the workings of the Party. It is done mainly through the use of single, isolated aspects of the story. Firstly, the fact that there is only one character who retains notoriety for being a detractor, an enemy, of the communist Party, and that character happens to be illiterate; in other words, he can't read the slogans and therefore can't rally around them like the masses do. Secondly, the fact that, despite relying largely on school and teaching for its story, there is only essentially one scene actually set in a classroom, and it too involves nothing but reciting communist propaganda, and when the boy in question makes an honest mistake, his words are misinterpreted and an entire investigation is set up as a result.
The pathos present in these, among other aspects of this film, is what gives it its comedy and hence its satire. That said, while the examination of communism is very interesting, the film itself fails a little to really engage me. The comedy is there, but it isn't funny. The drama is there, but it isn't moving. I just don't think the right atmosphere was created to actually captivate me; there is very little music used to set the mood, and the acting isn't quite good enough to compensate. Similarly, the subplot of the romance between Andre and Diana doesn't quite work for me; there just appears to be no development of this relationship and so when it is consummated there is very little chemistry between the two. It just comes off as incomplete.
The only real drama is the subtle message of the sadness and worthlessness of this life; Andre is used as contrast, the voice of wisdom as it were, between this essentially brainwashed community and the outside, more civilised world. But in the end, the schoolkids, like the adults, are simply forced to completely immerse themselves in a lifestyle that serves only the purposes of the party (with free will eliminated from the equation), and in more ways than one the film illustrates the fact that this is an endless cycle. And to an external viewer, that's quite sad to see.
In summary, the film, and script in particular, are very cleverly worked to examine the life and politics of this isolated village. It is in the execution of the story where it fails to impress, but as far as I can see, that matters very little since I love a film with intricate underlying themes. As a political foray, it's close to perfect. As a film, it isn't. In very simple terms, four stars out of five.
5 out of 5 people found the following comment useful :-
Surprisingly good, 17 May 2002
Author: Yngvar Myrvold from Tonsberg, Norway
Low budget movies need something to draw attention to them, lacking big stars and great effects. Slogans has those somethings in spades! We get to know an Albanian teacher arriving at a country school, around 1984. He seems to be a sympathetic guy.
The school seems to be less interested in teaching the children real subjects than pushing communist propaganda down their throats. Much of the week is spent on the hillsides, where the pupils whitewash stones and arrange them into huge letters with slogans like "Long live international Communism". The slogans can be seen from far off, thus securing that no citizen will be able to avoid them. Unruly teachers and classes are punished with very long sentences! Comic and tragic scenes are plentiful as the people struggle with the whims of the local communist party and the school principal's unrequited love for one of the female teachers.
Post-war Albanian history is terribly strange, weird and bizarre. Sandwiched between Christian and Moslem influences, this mountaineous country was isolated for a very long time, due to the paranoia of their leader, Enver Hoxha. Sensing enemies (revisionists) all around him, he closed the borders and nixed any international co-operation. This movie gives a fair account of what life must have been like in Albania at the time. It's well made, a bit on the long side, but still worthwhile for those who seek unusual films.
4 out of 4 people found the following comment useful :-
ascetic picture of communist Albania, 5 February 2006
Author: tczekalski from Kraków, Poland
Wonderful picture of socialist Albania written in a discreet, almost ascetic way. The novel by Ylljet Alicka "Parullat" (Slogans) was a little changed and included in a story devoted especially for Western cinemas (f.e. the sketch of a popular judge - not real and far from the Albanian realities). The main value of the film is the picture of mentality enslaved people. The slogans, like in the title are the occasion for the expressing of the dictator's cult. Director made this film only with the experienced actors, without new faces. Their roles are very static but it is a specific for this film. The dialogs, carries by the main actors (especially during the funeral) are based on the old rules, the principles of Kanun - the Albanian customary law. The portraits of High Albania very unique in the post 1990 movies, but in many corners of this country it is still a reality - it is not necessary to create something artificial. Ona of the rare cases in which Albanian film could be known wider than in the homeland country. And also it is a good way to understand what really was Albanian communism and how deeply was written in human souls.
1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
The most disturbing thing is that this really happened!, 17 January 2007
Author: the_fifth from Canada
*** This comment may contain spoilers ***
I read all the comments posted here and I can't hide the happiness that overwhelmed me when I saw people from different backgrounds being so deep and understanding about a culture that they don't seem to know. I am an Albanian myself but I can't say I experienced the communist regime in my country (I was only 3 when the system was overthrown) and I don't know if I should be sad or glad about that. Anyways I haven't seen the movie in quite a while but I remember that I was shocked when I first saw it although my parents have made everything possible to illustrate the environment in which they lived through stories and pictures. I couldn't believe all of that and like most people who saw it I thought it was exaggerated. When I asked my parents they told me that every scene of that movie was TRUE and it must have happened not only in rural areas, but even in the capital. People were being put on trial not only for "stabbing communism" or "for showing little effort in Marxism and Leninism" and other bullshit like that, but also for growing a beard/hair, wearing a sweater that is considered "foreign show" (literally) or even for not being present on a parade/volunteer actions etc. Somebody said that the love line between the two teachers (Andre and Diana ) was not satisfactory. It is my 'duty' to say here that this movie is really true to what actually happened. Don't expect a big Hollywood story with fireworks on the background and pink champagne on the ice! If they would show passion or whatever (even if they would smile at each-other) the villagers would start to talk, and they would accuse you of behaving improperly, they would transfer you and your family from the capital to a lost mountainous village on the North and even though you would have finished university you would be forced to work in agriculture. About the cast: I know almost all the actors that play in that movie, and they are definitely some of the best in my country. The way they acted was natural. This movie is supposed to be absurd. The lines are supposed to be stiff. They did an excellent job and I hope the director will do other hopefully with a different theme. For people that are really interested in communism and the absurd yet real way it's perceived and lived I would strongly suggest a book from a world-renowned Albanian writer named Ismail Kadare. The title is "Night without the Moon" if I'm not mistaken (something close anyway). It's an excellent book but unfortunately I'm not even sure if this one is actually translated in other languages. Anyways, enjoy!
1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
Very good!, 3 February 2003
Author: Gordon-11 from Hong Kong
*** This comment may contain spoilers ***
This film is an Albanian film that talks about life in a village school in a Communist country. The teachers were suppressed by the Party officials. If the Party officials did not like a teacher, then the teachers and their class of children would have to build longer slogans on the mountain using stones. Also it talked about the poverty of the villagers, that they have no money to replace torn clothing or worn out shoes. Another thing it talked about is that, if you have another political idea other than the Party officials' ideas, then you would be punished very heavily.
For the first time, I see what Albania is like. For me, Albania is very mysterious, because it was closed to the outside world completely until a few yeas ago. From this film, I understand that Albania is still underdeveloped, and the villagers are quite poor and unhappy.
I would like to elaborate on the political surveillance and punishment that the villagers received (Possible spoilers). There was a little boy, about 6 or 7 years old, who had to give a short political talk about the world's political climate. He said that China is a revisionist country, instead of a Socialist country, by mistake. He immediately corrected his mistake and apologised. However, on the following day this incident reached the Party officials, and the boy was detained for interrogation. The Party officials asked him who taught him that China is revisionist. The boy and his class teacher both insisted that it was only a careless and unintentional mistake. However, the Party officials were very convinced that the incident was a planned and vicious attack on Communism. The boy's father was arrested for sabotaging the stone slogans in the mountains (a crime that he never committed), and for "teaching" the little boy such ideas. He was sent to do hard labour. A teacher who defended the boy's father during a village meeting was accused of not being loyal to the Communist party, and was labelled "a danger to the people". He was sentenced to do 6 months of hard labour. As the story unveiled I became very upset. I simply cannot imagine what life is like under this environment. I imagine that, these people are living in terror every day. They do not dare to speak with other people, for fear that they will say something wrong and will be accused of some crimes.
However, this film may be exaggerating the situation, and may have dramatised the events. I enjoyed this film a lot, even though I was disturbed by the story. I hope what happened in the film is not reality.
0 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
One of the unknown faces of communism., 29 October 2002
Author: pajarobelga (pajarobelga@eresmas.com) from Soria, Spain
I've seen this film in the Festival International de Films d'Amour (Love film international festival) in Mons, Belgium, while spending one year in Belgium as an Erasmus student. This film was one the greatest surprises of the festival. However, it wasn't on competition. I agree with the previous spectator's opinion. I have to add a commentary about one of the scenes I was shocked by: an extremely poor shepherd who cannot read or write is taken to court accused of being imperialist and opposed to communism. The reason? Some of his goats had moved some of the stones that composed the slogans the day before and was finally sent to prison. Too sad. If you have the possibility of seeing the film, go for it.
Add another comment
Related Links