IMDb > About a Girl (2001) > IMDb user comments

IMDb user comments for
About a Girl (2001) More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 6 comments in total 

3 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
Humourous, touching and shocking portrait of the life of a working-class teenage girl in northern England., 11 March 2003
Author: info-1094 from London, Englnd

This is a film that really makes you think about our culture and our society today.

We learn about the life of the Girl as she talks about her hopes, dreams and experiences.

Nothing will prepare you for the very shocking ending. It really is like a slap in the face! Or a wake up call...

An excellent piece of writing, directing and acting.

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
A shocking picture of a neglected teenager., 26 February 2002
7/10
Author: damian_days from London, England

I had to see this film twice to truly appreciate it. So many short films are BOOORIIING, and I guess I expected this one to be also, so maybe I was predjudiced. I paid little attention to what was being said so did not get into the film, but then suddenly I was hit by a real wake-up call at the end. SO, I went to see it again, and I have to say the performance and characterisation of the central character IS superb. The actress really makes this film a winner. The direction of her is very good, though I found the photography a little flat, but perhaps this is because it is meant to be gritty and realistic. Overall it's a wonderful short film, but it deals with a grim subject. Not a popcorn film.

Was the above comment useful to you?

4 out of 5 people found the following comment useful :-
Devastating portrait of a young girl and her doomed life., 2 September 2002
8/10
Author: Havan_IronOak from NYC

Shocking short-film about a young girl who's the product of a broken home and hopeless dreams of being a pop star. Her dad is unemployed and spends his time playing soccer while her mom struggles to make end meet.

One striking feature of this film was the contrast by the girl's fully Americanized rendering of the pop lyrics she sings and the thick Liverpool accent that she uses in everyday speech. (It required me to put on subtitles to understand what was being said)

As sad as the life that she describes is, I was still totally unprepared for the ending.

Was the above comment useful to you?

2 out of 2 people found the following comment useful :-
Needs to be seen twice, 23 August 2002
Author: bob the moo from Birmingham, UK

A working class girls sings Brittany with her friends and talks excitedly about her life as she walks along the canal. However her story hints at hurts that go deeper than her talk suggest.

This short won the 2001 Bafta for best short film and was director Percival's first film after many years in commercials. The film starts with a well framed shot of the girl singing and dancing to a Brittany Spears song before going straight into a montage of her talking, hanging out with her Dad, on a bus with her friends etc. As it goes this is entertaining enough and quite interesting. The only weakness of it is that it feels like mix of two Fast Show characters – the `Brilliant' guy and the teenage girl.

However this is a minor complaint as the ending reveals the meaning behind much of her talk and the scenes we see. This really needs to be seen twice or followed by some thought to appreciate the significance of what has gone before the ending.

Thewlis is excellent. Managing to hold the screen well and be totally believable in the role. To one who is annoyed by loud teenagers singing pop songs on buses she did well to win me over.

Overall this is not an easy film to think about and does have a scene that many people will find upsetting (if only temporarily). While it feels aimless for most of your first viewing, a good performance by Thewlis is more than enough to hold the attention.

Was the above comment useful to you?

2 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
more to this than you think, 27 December 2003
Author: lyn50 from Australia

As I was watching it, I kept thinking of the similarities to parts of The Fast Show (aka Brilliant! in the US): the "Brilliant!" walking monologues with Paul Whitehouse, and Caroline Aherne's teenage monologues.

But don't be fooled. There is much more to this short film than meets the eye at first, and you'll probably want to watch it again.

Was the above comment useful to you?

A shocking picture of a neglected teenager., 26 February 2002
7/10
Author: damian_days from London, England

I had to see this film twice to truly appreciate it. So many short films are BOOORIIING, and I guess I expected this one to be also, so maybe I was predjudiced. I paid little attention to what was being said so did not get into the film, but then suddenly I was hit by a real wake-up call at the end. SO, I went to see it again, and I have to say the performance and characterisation of the central character IS superb. The actress really makes this film a winner. The direction of her is very good, though I found the photography a little flat, but perhaps this is because it is meant to be gritty and realistic. Overall it's a wonderful short film, but it deals with a grim subject. Not a popcorn film.

Was the above comment useful to you?

Add another comment

Related Links

Ratings Awards Plot keywords
Main details Your user comments Your vote history