IMDb on iPhone and iPod touch Learn more Learn more Download from the App Store
IMDb > The Circle (2005) > IMDb user comments

IMDb user comments for
The Circle (2005) More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 10 comments in total 

9 out of 11 people found the following comment useful :-
Spectacular, 7 February 2007
10/10
Author: sheckyicecream from United States

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

This film was absolutely fascinating. To pull off an entire movie in one continuous shot seems an unattainable feat, but Yuri Zeltser conquers it masterfully. The amazing part of this story is that I didn't notice it was unedited until I read the back of the DVD case - then I went back through the movie and was astonished by the direction and camera work throughout the one-and-a-half hour film. The fact that it was an action/drama even makes it more astounding because these movies often require the most takes. It is a sharp, intelligent and suspenseful tale that plays out like dream. A dream in which the main character, Angela Bettis can't wake up from and turns out to be a horrible nightmare in the end. David Proval also was impressive in his role as a contract killer with a rough edge, but a soft side that shines through with the help of Angela Bettis' character. This film has earned my recommendation and will surely surprise you as film unravels.

Was the above comment useful to you?

10 out of 13 people found the following comment useful :-
The Circle, A REAL Independent, 20 February 2007
8/10
Author: hdale04 from United States

Very unusual experience this film. Refreshingly, I didn't know what to expect at any given moment. The energy of the film was almost gorilla-like. The filming of the movie seemed very raw and simplistic, with a mysterious feel. I found myself eerily captivated. And the most interesting part is the dialog, simple, yet if you don't pay attention, you miss so much, even the most inane conversation is important to the plot line, brilliant! This is the first truly independent film I've seen in years. I recommend this film to anyone tired of the clean Hollywood feel of so called "independent films" these days. If you want an honest, no frills movie experience, check out this movie, you won't know WHAT hit you when your done!

Was the above comment useful to you?

8 out of 10 people found the following comment useful :-
I still can't believe they did it, 27 October 2007
9/10
Author: bernie-122 from Sydney, Australia

Don't pay any attention to one-star reviews by total idiots. This is one of the most, if not THE most amazing piece of film-making I've ever seen. And I'd like to know why the ONLY one-star review is the one featured on the main page. Who decides which review should be the leading one?

At first I thought it was done in 3 or 4 takes, which would have been impressive enough, but upon watching it again, I see it really is one continuous scene, start to finish. I don't see how anybody could pull that off. One mistake, one prop out of place, one line-fluff is all it would take, and you'd have to start all over again. This requires planning and execution beyond imagining, at least for me.

I could say that it got a bit over the top in the melodrama at times, but did it really? I'd have to say it all fitted with the surreal mood of the whole film.

I can't really say much more, else I'd risk giving away too much. If you like, or at least don't mind, something really different for a change, then please don't miss this.

Was the above comment useful to you?

9 out of 12 people found the following comment useful :-
Unique Experience of Pure Cinema, 19 July 2007
10/10
Author: Claudio Carvalho from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

Stan (Scott Cohen) is a hit man hired by the mobster Dad (David Provel) to kill Rick (Henry Czerny), the husband of Jay (Angela Bettis). While waiting for his final instructions from Dad in a low budget hotel, Stan is visited by Jay, who begs for the life of Rick. He breaks his own rules and explains that only Dad may break his contract, and Jay decides to visit Dad in his night-club to claim for Rick's life. After meeting Dad, Jay comes back home to Rick, when secrets are disclosed.

I bought this DVD without any previous reference, just based on the name of one of my favorite actresses, the stunning Angela Bettis. "The Circle" is simply spectacular, an unique experience of pure independent cinema as art, disclosing an intriguing and disturbing story in an environment nightmare and shot in only one take in real time. The logistic of the script, planning routes and rehearsals necessary to make this film would be enough to give a ten to the writer, director, cast and crew. In 2003, Lars von Trier presented to the world the sensational and original "Dogville", a bitter play about a town with disgusting dwellers with an awesome story of human exploitation and pay back. Yuri Zeltser gives this unknown masterpiece of experimental cinema, with a great tale about sinners trapped in the purgatory (or maybe in hell - in this case, Dad certainly is the devil). Every character is actually dead: Stan and Jay committed suicide or died through lethal injection; the cop, Hilga and Rick were shot; Dad was ill; Mom probably had an OD and Sing probably was murdered by Dad. Angela Bettis deserves an Oscar for her performance, and the cast has magnificent interpretations. The camera is fantastic, following the characters uninterruptedly through the most difficult angles and situations. Last but not the least, this film is highly indicated for movie lovers that aim to see a refreshing and absolutely original edition of a film. My vote is ten.

Title (Brazil): "O Círculo da Morte" ("The Circle of Death")

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 4 people found the following comment useful :-
The Circle, 21 February 2007
Author: Scarecrow-88 from United States

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

Angela Bettis stars as a troubled young wife of a man being set-up for a hit thanks to "Dad"(David Proval). She convinces the The Contract(Scott Cohen)to not go ahead with the planned hit, but must coerce Dad to take away the order to kill. Her journey is the large part of this film as Bettis walks a hell of a lot in this film shot in one long continuous take from director Yuri Zeltser. The film is snake-bit by hammy overacting theatrics from a game cast who seem to try too hard for realism and melodramatic depth. The cast is also saddled with corny, sometimes embarrassing, dialogue as well. Not to mention, the film is full of weird characterizations creating an oddball experience which may or may not be the intent. Strange movie. The title is essentially referring to a never-ending cycle..or some sort of nightmarish limbo, is you wish.

Was the above comment useful to you?

4 out of 6 people found the following comment useful :-
Pure Genius, 20 January 2008
10/10
Author: interspace from United Kingdom

This movie -- absolutely fantastic! On the technical level it's pure genius -- a single uninterrupted take, almost a hundred minutes, is spellbinding. The director, Yuri Zeltser, has performed a miracle, plain and simple. Well, not too simple -- making this movie must have been a mammoth undertaking. Now, the story starts off as a thriller/mystery, but then dives deeper and deeper into human psychology and metaphysics. Mindbending, almost hallucinogenic stuff. The acting -- stunning, especially the brilliant Angela Bettis. Why aren't we seeing more of this amazing actress? One exception -- David Proval (from the Sopranos), who thinks he is Al Pacino and overacts a bit (to put it mildly). Overall -- grand entertainment. 10 stars out of ten.

Was the above comment useful to you?

2 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
A Masterpiece, 22 January 2008
10/10
Author: Angela Condrene from Nice, France

This film was recommended to me by an old friend who knows and loves movies. He said -- this is something special. He was right. The film is a real masterpiece. Everything in it, the story, the direction, the acting is first class. And very entertaining, too! But what makes it really special is, of course, that it has no montage -- it was shot without edits. Amazing! The French DVD gives a good transfer, but the subtitles are not always in sync with the images. Not a big problem if you understand English, of course. Oh and another thing -- Scott Cohen is very sexy and interesting. I love this film and recommend it to anyone who loves cinema.

Was the above comment useful to you?

2 out of 6 people found the following comment useful :-
Interesting, but far from successful, 1 August 2007
6/10
Author: The_Void from Beverley Hills, England

I wasn't sure what to expect from this film, so I just went into it hoping for an enjoyable thriller. The Circle actually gets off to a fairly intriguing start, as we are introduced to the main characters - Stan, a hit man and Jay; the wife of the man he was hired to kill. The first half of the film plays out pretty much like a straight thriller as we watch the pair interact and end up getting themselves into a tricky situation; but then it would seem that the writer started experimenting with some strange hallucinogenic drugs as the film descends into the surreal, and rather than being interesting; it's mostly ridiculous - even the end twist (which is fairly imaginative) isn't enough to save what should have been a straight thriller. The central focus of the plot is on Jay and how she tries to persuade the hit man to not kill her husband. Obviously even going to see him puts her in a compromising position; but strangely it does him also.

The plot is fairly thin, and the focus is mainly on the characters. However, they're really not all that interesting; Scott Cohen is completely one-note as the hit man, while the usually solid Angela Bettis overacts to such an extend that I found myself feeling embarrassed for her at times. Whatever the director was trying to achieve with the characters really doesn't come off. There are a couple of interesting scenes; the best one being a lesbian(ish) sequence between Bettis and a stripper. The surreal elements of the film don't feel right considering the build up to them; I got the impression that the writer-director didn't really know where to take the film after the initial plot was set out, though maybe he always had the idea for where the film was going and the plot is the filler - either way, The Circle is one disjointed movie. Overall, I can't say that this film is without its merits - there are a few, but really I'd just call it a failed experiment.

Was the above comment useful to you?

36 out of 76 people found the following comment useful :-
One of the most amazing movies ever made, 24 June 2005
10/10
Author: mofilmvie from United States

Saw this movie in Cannes, and can't stop thinking about it. What an amazing piece of work! First of all, technically it's astounding -- the film is done in one uninterrupted take, and the visual acrobatics of this Mount Everest of shots are just incredible. I can't even begin to imagine the amount of planning, rehearsals, sweat and tears that went into this "one-shot wonder". Second, the story, the performances, and everything else in this movie is just brilliant. Angela Bettis -- where have you been hiding all my life? An unbelievable actress who grabs you by the throat (and the heart) and never lets go. All in all, this is a heartbreaking, inspiring, visionary movie -- a modern masterpiece.

Was the above comment useful to you?

4 out of 16 people found the following comment useful :-
Almost Not Worth Another Watch, 3 March 2007
1/10
Author: gonzo_don from United States

Obviously, I'm going to have to watch this inane waste of time again just to see what all the reviewers are raving about. From the opening shot when the hit man's phone rings and he looks at it like a caveman looking at the control panel of a Boeing 747, I knew I was in for a real piece of overacting. And I wasn't disappointed. Quick jerk of the neck, raised eyebrow, and a ponderous, "Hmmmm. What is this object on the nightstand that's emitting a ringing tone?" 43 seconds later, he figured it out and answered the damned thing... Everybody overacts. Even the "real" people. I think perhaps it was less an "amazing 90 minute one take" piece of directing and more of a "Hey! We've got a 90 minute tape in this camcorder--let's make a movie!" Don't waste your time.

Was the above comment useful to you?


Add another comment


Related Links

Plot summary Ratings External reviews
Plot keywords Main details Your user comments
Your vote history