We though it was pure lounge music, right down to the handkerchief pinned to his jacket pocket. Are you supposed to pin those things on the outside? It should be obvious to anyone with working ears that American Idol is not the place for Andrew Garcia to be singing. He’s out of his comfort zone and floundering terribly.
Randy Jackson: I hate to say this, but Simon Cowell kind of predicted it earlier. That was not good karaoke. I didn’t like it, I didn’t get it at all. This is Elvis, one of the greatest ever.
Ellen DeGeneres: I have your back too, because