In Ravenswood Miranda and Caleb find a tombstone with their names and pictures on. Caleb meets Remy, who helps him investigate, and siblings Olivia and Luke, who recently lost their father in mysterious circumstances.
After Miranda's funeral, Caleb tells Remy, Luke and Olivia that he has seen her. The four decide to stick together for their safety. Caleb moves into Miranda's uncle's guest house. After a dangerous séance, all the five teens see Miranda.
The Ravenswood Police make an arrest for the murder of Luke and Olivia's father. Mr. Price (recurring guest star JUSTIN BRUENING) inadvertently sends Caleb and Miranda on a quest to investigate a secret Collins has been keeping, but it leads them to some startling insight about the pact. With questions about Dillon (recurring guest star LUKE BENWARD) swirling, Olivia is confused when he finally shows up to help her through her latest crisis. And Remy and Luke are determined to prove that Dillon has been hiding something, which puts Luke in danger. Meanwhile, Caleb starts school in Ravenswood and Miranda tries to keep him company, leading to an awkward incident.