While on a freight run with Murphy, Matt Sims witnesses a bank robbery by his friend Nolan and Nolan's two very bad brothers. Matt struggles with the disappointment that someone he looked up to could let him down so much. Nolan struggles when he realizes he made a mistake robbing with his brothers. A number of events leads Matt to turn in Nolan after promising he wouldn't. Then all at Gold Hill must figure out a way to keep Nolan from hanging for the crime.