Salem is terrified to learn that the evil Toc-Toc is being released from suspended animation (a Netherworld corrections facility) for a crime Salem committed! No doubt, Toc-Toc is coming to seek revenge! Sabrina encourages Salem to talk to Toc-Toc, but the frightened cat insists on going to school with Sabrina disguised as a sporty teen. Toc-Toc arrives on earth also disguised as an adolescent, and hurries to Greendale High in search of Salem. Sabrina and Salem are convinced that Rex, a new student, is Toc-Toc in disguise, so Sabrina uses magic to land him in detention. When Rex meets the real Toc-Toc, the evil aggressor is convinced that Rex is Salem in disguise! Salem is perfectly happy to let Rex get punished instead of him, but Sabrina persuades her cat to take responsibility for his own actions. After Salem reveals himself, Sabrina convinces Toc-Toc that life with her is MUCH worse than any punishment he could give Salem, so Toc-Toc agrees to let Salem stay with the torturous ...