The American Scream (2012) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
"When you're scared, you're most alive; people need that"
StevePulaski30 October 2012
The American Scream examines four different people from the state of Maine as they each prepare for Halloween by constructing their own homes into haunted houses for the neighborhood to visit. One would perhaps call these men amateurs, although I'm not sure how to differentiate a professionally built haunted house from an amateur one. From what I can see, the props and the methods used by the men and from some of the haunted houses I've experiences there wasn't much difference.

I personally can't stand haunted houses. I love horror films, but am not fond of being confined to a small, murky, crowded, foggy area for long periods of time. I can, however, appreciate the craft these enthusiasts put into these projects. Victor Bariteau works at a financial company, repairing servers and desperately trying to keep his head afloat in the corporate filed to support his wife and two girls. Every year, he constructs a haunted house from parts he makes or finds in hopes to leave a mark on the neighborhood. Father and son team Rick and Matt Brodeur get much of their haunted house equipment from their overcrowded basement, which to one person looks like a junk-heap, but to another, horror-heaven with various marks, lights, statues, figurines, costumes, signs, and memorabilia. The final person is Manny Souza, a frequent helper on sculptures and props for Victor. Souza constructs his own houses as well, saying that he often favors quantity of sculptures and props over detail, unlike Victor who wants details to be painstakingly fleshed out. He believes that people come to simply walk through, be scared, and move on; not eye details in complete awe.

We too examine the relationship the men hold with their family. Victor shows how his oldest daughter, around ten, loves horror and monster seasons so much so that she will mutilate and discolors the bodies of her Barbie dolls to almost resemble something out of Saw or Wolf Creek. Rick and Matt appear to have an incorruptible brotherly bond, even attending different organizations dressed as clowns with inspiration from duos like Laurel and Hardy under their belt.

One thing we also notices is the level of stress and angst these men and their families are put under during the month of October. We wonder, especially in Victor's case, if his family members even appreciate the fact he does this since his wife often seems miserable around Halloween, slaving over costumes and makeup, never appearing to rise above the level of content to her husband's passion. We see these men work incredibly hard at building these houses and concocting intricate little scares for just one night and we sense an overwhelming dedication and pride on their part.

Director Michael Paul Stephen son, most recently famous for Best Worst Movie, a documentary examining Troll 2, another film he worked on, and how its reputation of being the worst film of all time has affected it positively and negatively, gives great care and attention to this subject, emphasizing its ups, yet not ignoring its down as as a whole. He too seems to compliment the privilege of meeting these men four men and studying their passion. These men deserve recognition; it appears that they are not taking money from this haunted house operation, since no talk of financial figures is ever brought up. It seems to sum up Victor's goal and reward at the end by saying, "when you're scared, you're most alive; people need that."

Starring: Victor Bariteau, Rick Brodeur, Matt Brodeur, and Manny Gouza. Directed by: Michael Paul Stephenson.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Good Documentary If a Bit Slow At Times
Michael_Elliott29 October 2012
The American Scream (2012)

*** (out of 4)

From Michael Stephenson, the director of BEST WORST MOVIE, comes this rather charming documentary focusing on three people whose love of Halloween causes them to turn their homes into a haunted house tour on the holiday. THE American SCREAM is a rather interesting documentary, although it's certainly flawed at times as well as being a tad bit slow. I think most people love Halloween and as this film shows, people love using their imagination and getting scared. I think some of the best moments talk about not only these three men but also various others across the country who spend thousands of dollars decorating their homes and trying to outdo one another for having the best haunted house. I think some other great moments include the obvious effect this is having on some of the people but this here is also the bad part of the film. I think the movie needed more scenes taking a look at the bad times of doing this. There are times when finances are mentioned and it would have been nice hearing about how much this costs and what sacrifices these people have to make to make others happy. The pacing is a bit off and as I said, at 82-minutes the film does seem long at times. With that said, the movie is still very much worth watching.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
A bit slow but worth a look
MartinHafer28 October 2012
This documentary follows three families in Massachusetts as they prepare for incredibly elaborate lawn displays for Halloween. There is no narration--just shots of the various folks working and talking to the camera about their obsession to perfect their haunted houses and lawn displays. Much of it is a bit slow, but there also is a certain oddness that makes it watchable.

As I watched the film, I sure wondered about the mental states of these people and their lives. They clearly have issues and you wonder about the long-term effects on these guy's families--as well as so much stress that at several of these guys clearly are NOT enjoying this process. It's not really a's an all-consuming obsession. And, as such, would be an interesting film to show a psychology class. However, for the average viewer this might just be a case of too much. Because the film is so long, it does drag a bit and might put off some due to this. Still, it's worth a look.
6 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Pop Culture Thoughts
popculturethoughts15 December 2018
Michael Paul Stephenson's lovingly assembled and perceptive documentary's impact goes beyond that of its central subject: Namely, it quickly establishes itself as a sympathetic, sensitive analysis of "home haunters" (which are described as people who make a tradition out of decorating their homes for Halloween) that's not limited to their aspirations but instead focuses on their families, goals and personal passions that have become guiding principles. It's really something special to witness, and will surely delight fans of Halloween, while fans of peculiar personalities like those found in 1975's classic "Grey Gardens" may find something to appreciate here as well.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Behind The Scenes of Home Haunters!
laneybugg20 July 2018
I personally loved this! I thought it was interesting to watch the process of a home haunter: the desire, the stress, the work, the thrill, the enjoyment, etc. I enjoyed every second of this! ..And now, I must step up my game!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
The American Dream...
poe-4883318 April 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Until I saw THE American SCREAM, I had no idea what I wanted to do with the remainder of my Life. Now, I know. No, I don't want to spend whatever time I've got left building haunted houses (as do the stalwarts herein): what I'd like most to do is find a place like Fairhaven and settle down there- near people of a like mind, with the right disposition(s). Halloween has always been far and away my favorite holiday; nothing else even comes close (although there's a lot to be said for Thanksgiving...). To live in a town where Halloween is celebrated every day would be a dream come true, the only way to go; the Most, Daddy-o- with drive-ins and all-night horrorthons every weekend and conventions and weekly get-togethers and... Well, one can DREAM, can't one...?
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Rest in Pieces
tieman6424 December 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Overlong but touching, Michael Stephenson's "The American Scream" centres on a group of working class men who turn their homes into elaborate haunted houses during Halloween. Set in Massachusetts, the film watches as our heroes risk financial ruin, their marriages and sanity for the happiness of others. Their little sacrifices are poignant, as is the way Stephenson portrays Halloween as a means of communal bonding and creative expression.

Less successful are Stephenson's attempts to delve into the psyches of his leads. Aside from one man, a computer programmer who was brought up within a strict, conservative household, Stephenson's leads are held at a distance. Perhaps this is best. "I don't understand my reasons," one says, echoing the summations of artists throughout the ages. "The American Scream" offers Halloween as a time of sacrifice, community, and an almost irrational giving of one's self over to the audience.

7.9/10 – Worth one viewing.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews

Recently Viewed