When a pregnant 23-year-old Iowa woman is shot in her own bed, investigators must quickly determine if they are looking for someone with a deadly grudge against the couple or a more sinister culprit closer to home.
In Cleveland, a 14-year-old African-American girl is snatched off the street, assaulted and murdered on her way to school. Initially, detectives work the case 24/7. But it will take a lucky break and nearly 30 years before the culprit is behind bars.
On her last day as a high school freshman, a 14-year-old girl is brutally beaten and set on fire. The horrifying crime sends shockwaves through her California community and with a possible serial killer on the loose, investigators hunt for a monster.
Popular schoolteacher Marilyn Habian is shot in the heart in the basement of her Cleveland-area home. And years after the case goes cold, news of a potential prison confession leads investigators back to her front door.
A devout Mormon and popular University student, 19-year-old Brooke Wilberger is abducted from an Oregon parking lot in broad daylight. Police immediately launch a massive search and the story of the missing 19-year-old soon captures headlines nationwide.
It's a September morning in 1973, and Debra Dill's bludgeoned body is discovered next to her car in rural Maine. Her grieving community wakes up to a nightmare, but it will take nearly two decades before the killer is behind bars.