The Id (2015) Poster

(2015)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Sensational...Negative Reviews Explained
psmyre6 March 2017
This was a masterwork of dramatic acting. I've rarely seen an actor bring such realism and intensity to a role. This is not a horror film, per se, but a realistic trip down the rabbit hole of a highly dysfunctional parent-child relationship. Amanda Wyss absolutely nails her role as Meridith, drawing the viewer in on a dark journey of her addled psyche. Patrick Peduto serves as an excellent co-dependent foil in her emotionally abusive father. For anyone with leftover issues from childhood - that is, just about all of us - it can be disturbing. However, this movie's power to make you think about your own life is highly redemptive, unpacked as it is under the protective blanket of make-believe.

The Meridith character is none of the things she is accused of by her father. In fact, she's just the opposite. Far from being a "slut," she clearly wants a loving, monogamous relationship with a decent man. However, she is imprisoned by the confines of her history of dysfunction. Meridith can only dream of the reality she so craves. The only thing left to her is memories of what might have been. This is a wake-up call to any real Meridiths out there. If you have unloving or abusive parents or partners, what they think of you should not be taken as gospel. There is a whole world out there, filled with many people capable of seeing what you have to offer and what makes you special.

As for the excess of negative reviews, they are in no way a fair criticism of the acting or the directing. In the latter case, young Thommy Hutson brings a complex, multi-layered story to life. He packs with it with stark symbolism that makes the story itself even more vivid and compelling. So, in a nutshell, the acting, directing, and writing are nothing short of superb. The problem is that there are so many people who recoil from staring down that rabbit hole that is their own past. Instead of engaging in thoughtful self-examination, they lash out with a negative review. When we're watching "Nightmare on Elm Street," we can walk away protected by the assurance that Freddy Krueger doesn't exist. That's not so easy with "The Id." Both the character of Meridith and of her father are people so many of us can relate to. Some such viewers aren't ready for that sort of exploration, but that's okay. What's not okay is to misdirect your feelings into an unfair written critique.

For reviewers of any kind of performance art, I encourage them to confine their remarks to correspond with the genre on which said art is based. For instance, I dislike most horror movies. When I saw "The Exorcist" years ago, it scared the pants off me, and I didn't enjoy the experience. However, within the horror genre, I had to admit that it was a classic. To call "The Exorcist" a lousy movie would have been grossly inaccurate.

In closing, "The Id" is not a movie that fits a night of mindless decompression after a hard day's work. If that's what you're looking for, pop open a beer and rent "The Naked Gun" or "Scream." But if you want an emotionally evocative experience that will stay with you and make you think, I can't think of a better option than "The Id." I would call this movie a "psychological thriller/tragedy" in lieu of categorizing it as horror. The occult makes no appearance in this film; it's all about what is swimming around in poor Meridith's head. So, be brave and watch this movie. After your more visceral feelings go away, you will find that it was both enlightening and gripping.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
You want to see my bedroom?
nogodnomasters2 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This is a psychological thriller and not much horror. It is not for everyone and I am going to include a mid point PLOT SPOILER in this review. Meredith Lane (Amanda Wyss) cares for her father (Patrick Peduto). Their meals are delivered (Jamye Grant). They have a verbally abusive relationship, and it appears sometimes physically abusive, although we don't see much of that. From what we can gather, mom left when Meredith was a child. As a teen Meredith was a hot number. She gets a call from an old boyfriend Ted, who claims he wants to drop by. Dad is against it and makes life miserable for the over medicated Meredith.

The film opens with a boring monologue on love in need of a thesaurus for "true" and "truly." We see Meredith slowly descend into madness in a variation of (plot spoiler time) "The Tell-Tale Heart." It was clear Sean H. Stewart was inspired by the story. Amanda Wyss was just phenomenal in her role, it overpowered the production.

Guide: F-word, sex, Patrick Peduto shows his junque.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Decent Vehicle for Wyss
bettybenzone17 June 2019
Amanda Wyss has been one of those interesting character actors who's been working forever and, yet, she's rarely been given the chance to really show what she's made of. The Id finally gives her the chance to step up to the plate and she hits it out of the park as Meredith - a lonely, put upon woman who still lives with her her abusive father and has absolutely no life of her own. When a former flame walks into her life, she tries to get her life back together, but it's no use. She's doomed from the start.

The Id isn't a very hard film to predict where it's going and there's not a mood of enough gloom and doom to make us feel like we're watching high tragedy. The script is fairly pedestrian without many surprises, but it's a testament to Wyss that it still stays quite watchable to the end. I can only imagine what she'd be able to pull off with a better written role.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed